There was no armenian genocide april 23, 2014 at 10. The armenian genocide also known as the armenian holocaust was the systematic mass murder and expulsion of 1. I was recently approached by a facebook friend who asked me for some informati. The treatment of armenians in the ottoman empire is a book written by viscount bryce and arnold j. Armenian genocide for the purpose of propaganda show as a reference and even qualify as an absolute must. I didnt expect to open a book on the armenian genocide and have it begin at faneuil hall. The history of the armenian speaking people 2018 by michael boyajian published by jera studios publishing pp. The treatment of armenians in the ottoman empire often referred to as the blue book in turkish sources is a book written by viscount bryce and arnold j. However, as i demonstrate in my book, the armenian massacres in ottoman turkey. Copies were first sent to turkish deputies in 2009, but distribution was prevented in ankara. Ankara blue book, which contains eyewitness account of the armenian genocide, has been sent to the turkish parliament by post, agos reports.
The blue book, political truth or historical fact wikipedia. These and others have told that the blue book the treatment of armenians in the ottoman. Dadrian claims that this number increased to 2,345 in the weeks that followed. All information provided in the blue book is cataloged and can be traced to the original source predominantly located in the united states national archives. It is the the most informative, concise and to the point compilatio. Apr 24, 2015 armenian genocide photo collection shows world the true horror. The blue book has been one of the most solid and influential sources on the armenian genocide. I pointed out the strength of the various accounts that underpinned the british report. Oxford university armenian society and aegis society just hosted the screening of the blue book, witnessing history, a new observational documentary examining turkeys efforts to deny armenian genocide. Week by week 100 years later s2 e15 the armenian genocide i the great war week 37 duration. A memoir of the armenian genocide, 19151918, trans. The release of the blue book demonstrates these efforts. Apr 21, 2015 untangling the truth from the myth of the armenian genocide by. It was a holocaust, but the eu is too afraid to ad.
The blue book, political truth or historical fact is a 2009 documentary film by gagik karagheuzian about the armenian genocide denial. Uk should apologize to turkey about armenian genocide claims elekdag says armenian genocide claims stemmed from the blue book, published by the british in 1916, based on groundless and false documents. Varjabedian is the first and original book published with this title in 1977 about the armenians from prehistoric times to the present. Guenter lewy claims in his book,the armenian massacres in ottoman turkey. The focus of the interview was the british parliamentary blue book, the treatment of armenians in the ottoman empire, which was published in 1916. Oxford university armenian society and aegis society just hosted the screening of the blue book, witnessing history, a new observational documentary examining turkeys efforts to. Armenian books main page this page hosts a list of books on the armenian genocide. In 2005 the turkish grand national assembly tgna sent a petition to the british parliament, asking the latter to apologize for its 1916 publication, the treatment of armenians in the ottoman empire 19151916. The turkish publisher ragip zarakolu reminded journalists of what happened four years ago. Turkish parliament request for retraction of british. The blue book was targeted once more by the tbmm turkish parliament in 2005, when turkish parliamentarians embarked on another offensive, this time blaming the british parliament for the armenian genocide thesis. Documents presented to viscount grey of falloden by viscount bryce uncensored edition aka the blue book bryce, james, toynbee, arnold joseph, toynbee, arnold, sarafian, ara on. Noone denies that between 800,000 and 1,400,000 armenians died from the relocations authorised under the tehcir law of 27th may 1915. This is because arnold toynbee was the compiler and editor of this parliamentary report and the toynbee papers at the national archives include the complete copy of the blue book, information about the eyewitness accounts he collected on the armenian genocide when compiling the blue book, as well as his further correspondence with his.
But the standard turkish denial semantics are that the deaths were just the unfortunate results of a campaign. The latter book was all part of a propaganda campaign. The british government today refuses to recognise the armenian genocide of 1915. This book has been said to be a product of british.
James bryce armenian literature, history, religion, etc. Balakian in his own book the burning tigris credits with this work of validation, vahakn dadrian, is himself guilty of willful mistranslations, selective quotations, and other serious violations of scholarly ethics. The starting date is conventionally held to be 24 april 1915. Elekdag says armenian genocide claims stemmed from the blue book. In 1916 the british parliament published a blue book that identified the events of 191516 as a systematic effort to exterminate the armenian people. Collection of documents the treatment of armenians in the ottoman empire 19151916 or the blue book because of the color of its cover is.
The blue book, political truth or historical fact, a 2009 documentary film in support of the. Dec 11, 2000 the treatment of armenians in the ottoman empire, 19151916. The treatment of armenians in the ottoman empire, 1915. Genocide museum the armenian genocide museuminstitute. There is a legitimate historical controversy concerning the interpretation of the events in question and most of the scholars who have propounded a contra genocide viewpoint are of the highest calibre and repute, including bernard lewis. The work was published 100 years ago by james bryce, a british statesman, lawyer, historian, and arnold toynbee, a famous english historian, and introduced to the uk parliament in 1916.
Blue book sent to turkish parliament by post massispost. The blue book written by viscount bryce and arnold toynbee has been used as proof that armenians and the victims of the jewish holocaust suffered the same fate in history. In other words the blue book paints the ottoman policy, particularly the decision to separate the ottoman armenian civilians from the armenian rebels and russian army by relocating them out of the war zones, as a facade for racist killing. Armenian genocide in the period 1915 to 1917, between 1 and 1. Armenian genocide photo collection shows world the true. Sarafian got so shook up, he had to make amends by trying to validate this awful propagandistic work. British parlimentary report on armenian genocide published. Untangling the truth from the myth of the armenian genocide by. The starting date is conventionally held to be 24 april 1915, the day that ottoman authorities rounded up, arrested, and deported from constantinople now istanbul. The tbmm claimed that the eyewitness accounts in the blue book were fabricated or second rate.
Mar 24, 2018 blue book evidence of armenian genocide. A disputed genocide, that there is not enough evidence of the young turk regime organizing the killings of armenians in the ottoman empire. The british parliament needs to similarly apologize to turkey, especially since this groundless work continues to poison minds. Collection of documents the treatment of armenians in the ottoman empire 19151916 or the blue book because of the color of its cover is one of the monumental sources on the armenian genocide. The most commonly used reference of documents on the armenian genocide is the brycetoynbee blue book perhaps mr. Aug 22, 2012 the book titled the armenians by sisag h. Prior to our interview, i corresponded with the bbc production team. Khardalian is the director and producer of riveting new film called grandmas tattoos that lifts the veil of thousands of forgotten womensurvivors of the armenian genocidewho were. In 1916 the british parliament published a blue book that identified the events. In 1916 the british parliament published a blue book that identified the.
These and others have told that the blue book the treatment of armenians in the ottoman empire, 19151916 by james bryce and arnold j. Toynbee, first published in 1916, that contains a compilation of statements from eyewitnesses of the armenian genocide in the ottoman empire during 19151916. His opposition took him to turkey, where he addressed turkish historians and diplomats at an. Nonetheless, tusan points to this moment as key in shaping the understanding of the armenian genocide during that time. The blue book is an observational documentary, which scrutinizes one of these cases. The lies of the german blue book bayoneted babies, people made into soap resulted in a british apology to germany in 1936. Ninety years after publication, the blue book is key to the question of whether the massacre and deportation of the.
Uncensored edition of british blue book sheds light on armenian genocide. Nov 25, 2014 the blue book is an observational documentary, which scrutinizes one of these cases. At any rate, adalian offered the following desperate defense. Toynbee, first published in 1916, that contains a compilation of statements from eyewitnesses of the armenian genocide in the. Popular armenian genocide books goodreads share book. Documents presented to viscount grey of falloden by viscount bryce uncensored edition aka the blue book at. Apr 23, 2014 the following quotation from arnold toynbee, british historian and coauthor of the blue book, which is claimed to leave no doubt about what was taking place, clearly shows the extent of armenian false propaganda and how they come up with fabricated evidence. The tgna wanted the british parliament to declare it as false and. For instance, arnold toynbee and lord bryces blue book included impressive documentation of murder and violence, but with little eventual effects on the prosecution of those responsible.
Apr 03, 2020 armenian genocide, campaign of deportation and mass killing conducted against the armenian subjects of the ottoman empire by the young turk government during world war i 191418. In 2005, sarafian began a campaign to oppose the efforts of turkish parliamentarians in london to deny the armenian genocide of 1915. The blue book, political truth or historical fact is a 2009 documentary film by gagik karagheuzian about the armenian genocide denial synopsis. After previously unsuccessful attempts to get resolutions on it through congress, in 2000 the house international relations committee voted for a bipartisan resolution condemning the armenian genocide, while carefully exempting the turkish republic from any responsibility for it. Armenian genocide simple english wikipedia, the free. The most notable of his works concerning the armenian question is the collection of eyewitness accounts on the armenian genocide, compiled with the help of the famous historian arnold j. The british parliamentary blue book, which consists of eyewitness accounts of the armenian genocide, has been sent to the turkish parliament for a second time. Affirming the united states record on the armenian. The treatment of armenians in the ottoman empire, 19151916. Armenian genocide documentary armenian genocide blog. Nor did i expect the speaker quoted to be julia ward howe, the great abolitionist and feminist who gave.
Toynbee and published by the british government in 1916 under the title the treatment of armenians in the ottoman empire, 191516 also known as blue book. Armenians charge that the campaign was a deliberate attempt to destroy the armenian people and, thus, an act of genocide. If a book is missing, you can add it using the add a book form. Story of the blue book on genocide told in documentary the armenian reporter june 2, 2010. The blue book continues to reinforce misunderstanding of and hatred against people of turkish heritage. The treatment of armenians in the ottoman empire wikipedia. Untangling the truth from the myth of the armenian genocide. The blue book on genocide documentary armenian genocide blog. Like school students, the mps were protected from danedom there in turkish parliament, he said. This observational documentary traces the work of ara sarafian, an archival historian. A critical, uncensored edition, edited and with an introduction by ara sarafian, has now been published by the gomidas institute. This report was the first account of the armenians genocide using eyewitness testimonies. The armenian weekly reports that this friday, june 26th, a turkish translation of the much contested blue book, the famous 1916 report by the british government entitled, the treatment of armenians in the ottoman empire 191516, will be published in ankora by lord avebury and ara sarafian under. Sarafian is currently editor of gomidas institute books and coeditor of armenian forum.
There are, today in the world, a few books which thousands of writings, articles and books including claims for armenian genocide for the purpose of propaganda show as a reference and even qualify as an absolute must. A simple resolution is used for matters that affect just one chamber of congress, often to change the rules of the chamber to set. Contrary to the armenian allegations, in fact, there is no consensus among the historians and legal experts to qualify the events of 1915 as genocide. The armenian genocide was the forcible deportation and massacring of armenians during the government of the young turks from 1915 to 1917 in the ottoman empire.
117 1053 1226 877 1472 1038 565 1006 1425 1354 1117 1299 630 658 200 1153 962 638 127 591 672 902 50 338 1125 1012 19 540 708 1377 768 1002